
Peated single malt whisky is a single malt Scotch made from barley dried over burning peat, which gives the spirit its trademark smoky, phenolic character.
There’s no real substitute for the smoke — it’s the whole point of choosing this whisky. For body and proof, any 40%+ single malt works, but for the peat character stick within the peated family (a lighter Highland peated malt instead of a heavily peated Islay one, for a gentler smoke).
Unpeated single malt whisky
Same barley, same distillery, only the malt is kilned without peat. In a smoky highball the one thing the drink was built around is gone, and the only fix is the bottle you have not got — so pour it as a different, gentler drink rather than a repaired one.
Blended malt / blended Scotch whisky
A blend across several distilleries, and blended Scotch adds light grain on top of that. The smoke is diluted into the background: the cocktail comes out softer and more even; the peat stops leading.
Peatiness is measured in phenol ppm: the gentle bottlings run in single figures, the island ones reach fifty and beyond.

Peated Blood and Sand
Blended Scotch whisky

Penicillin
Blended Scotch whisky

Smoked Old Fashioned Godfather
Amaretto liqueur, Bourbon, Rye whiskey, Blended Scotch whisky

Islay Old Fashioned
Peated single malt whisky

Bloody Blood and Sand
Blended Scotch whisky, Cherry liqueur, Rosso vermouth

Dark & Smoky
Peated single malt whisky, Ginger beer

Tommy D Sour
Blended Scotch whisky

Smoky Whisky Sour
Peated single malt whisky, Blended Scotch whisky

Smoked Maple
Peated single malt whisky

Smoked Rob Roy
Peated single malt whisky

25th Hour
Peated single malt whisky

Kummel Ye Faithful
Mezcal

Mexican Nail
Tequila reposado